Jessica Chapel / Railbird

Mo Proof, Please

Early Kentucky Derby fave Uncle Mo has been branded by owner Mike Repole as a Great One, and in that, at this stage in the colt’s career, he’s less reminiscent of Seattle Slew — a Repole-favored comparison — than he is of Man o’ War, the most lauded horse of the early 20th century, still counted among the top three of all-time by most racing historians.

Much as the superlatives have been heaped on Mo, anointed this year’s Triple Crown hope, so the praise was on Man o’ War. The excitement for the Fair Play colt built early during his 2-year-old campaign, and was barely slowed by his famous half-length loss to Upset in the 1919 Sanford Stakes. At the end of the season, in which he went 9-for-10, often carrying a highweight of 130 pounds, the colt was deemed the greatest juvenile to have ever appeared in in the country. After Man o’ War won the 1920 Preakness Stakes, in his first start of the year, the argument began in earnest over whether he was greatest American thoroughbred ever to run, and it became something of a challenge to find starters willing to face the 3-year-old star. In his 10 starts following the Preakness, he never raced against more than three others. In several, such as the Lawrence Realization Stakes in which he set a world record of 2:40 4/5 for 1 5/8 miles, he raced against only one other.

Man o’ War, by this time frequently called “the horse of the century,” handily defeated 1919 Triple Crown winner Sir Barton in his final start, the 1920 Kenilworth Park Gold Cup, but few of his competitors from that year have names still familiar. In a bit of historical who’d-he-beat, the sparse fields of Man o’ War’s sophomore season have become reason to question his standing.

In his favor, though, Man o’ War never shirked. He was pointed to the top stakes of his time — among his wins are the Belmont Stakes, Travers Stakes, and Jockey Club Gold Cup — and he could only run against those with connections brave enough to face him. He was put into conditions to be tested. To say he was great wasn’t a mere opinion — it was a truth, as defined by what he consistently accomplished at the highest level.

With luck, Mo has many races ahead. He’s undeniably talented and fast, and his name, before long, may join the greats his record and speed so far recall. But there’s a difference between Uncle Mo and Man o’ War, between him and so many others cherished as great ones, and it’s not only his owner’s fervent, public dream for the colt’s near future, accepted by so many:

Uncle Mo may, indeed, be the next Seattle Slew and live up to the lofty expectations placed on him. The words Triple Crown were uttered here all afternoon by rival trainers, pedigree experts and breeding farm owners who are tracking the Uncle Mo camp as if they were coaches sizing up a basketball recruit. Every farm in central Kentucky wants to be the one to land the breeding deal for the first Triple Crown champion since Affirmed in 1978.

I think the great ones know they’re great,” said Repole after Uncle Mo won the first running of the ungraded one-mile Timely Writer at Gulfstream. The great ones also prove their greatness on track, and not in races written for them.


4 Comments

I don’t think Mr. Drape and I were watching the same race. Premier Pegasus is indeed closer to Video Ranger.

How often will his races set up perfectly like that?
Sub 22 and sub 1:09 ? It’s completely unreasonable to expect that.

Premier Pegasus may develop into a solid racehorse but he’s not going to run and hide in many of his future races.

Posted by The_Knight_Sky on March 15, 2011 @ 1:00 pm

*Sigh*, every year at this time one horse or another is being touted as among the greatest that every lived only to get injured or killed or otherwise crash and burn and fail the big test.

That miracle of modern chemistry, Big Brown comes to mind.

The truly wise don’t even start thinking about a Triple crown until at least after the Derby, so I suspect the hype at this time of the year is more wishful thinking than anything else.

Posted by tvnewsbadge on March 15, 2011 @ 11:10 pm

TVnewsbadge: Uncle Mo already passed a big test when he won the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile against the best two-year-olds, and nothing we have seen since indicates that he is no longer the best of his generation.

Yes, there’s still plenty left to prove, but right now Uncle Mo is the leader and worthy of discussion.

The great thing about horse racing is there is a place to lodge your opinions—the betting window. Good luck.

Posted by EJXD2 on March 17, 2011 @ 5:55 am

Oh, I’m not saying that Uncle Mo will not ultimately turn out to be a superior horse, only that every year at this time we hear the so-called experts proclaim a new flavor or the month the “greatest horse that ever lived” and then come Derby time they’re no longer relevant OR they fail the Triple Crown campaign.

I’m not saying Uncle Mo is not worthy of discussion, only that it’s incredibility silly to call him the greatest horse of his generation until he’s at LEAST won the Kentucky Derby given our past experiences with the realities of the sport.

Posted by tvnewsbadge on March 17, 2011 @ 10:53 am