Preakness Field in Flux
– With nine days to go, the Preakness has only six definite starters: Barbaro, Brother Derek, Sweetnorthernsaint, Like Now, Bernardini, and trainer Nick Zito’s morning glory, Hemingway’s Key. “I had this in mind from day one because I thought he was Belmont material,” said Zito of the colt, who finished eighth in his last start, the Lexington. Trainer D. Wayne Lukas, put off by Barbaro’s dominating win in the Derby, has decided not to enter Simon Pure, who finished fourth in the Arkansas Derby. “I think [Barbaro] should scare a few horses away — me included,” said Lukas. Lawyer Ron is also out — the colt is having surgery Friday to remove chips in his right hind ankle.
– Lawyer Ron wasn’t the only horse to exit the Derby with an injury. Sharp Humor has a knee fracture, for which he’ll have surgery today. “It was very unfortunate and now we know why he ran the way that he did,” said trainer Dale Romans. “He just didn’t run his race at all.” Sharp Humor finished 19th in the Derby.
“A Tremendous Machine”
Watch Secretariat win the Triple Crown, again and again and again …
(If the screen above doesn’t work, try this link.)
The Price of Greed
Yearling prices and syndication deals have changed the game and made winning the Triple Crown harder, not easier, Lowell Sun racing correspondent Paul Daley writes in this week’s Sun column, reprinted with permission here.
The past few days we’ve witnessed two notable defections from the Kentucky Derby Trail. First, two-year-old Eclipse Award winner Stevie Wonderboy suffered a hairline condylar fracture to his right front ankle on Monday morning, necessitating at least a 90-day absence from the racing wars. Then, on Tuesday, trainer Patrick Byrne declared Arlington Washington Futurity winner, Sorcerer’s Stone, out of the Triple Crown due to small ankle chips.
Thus, the Derby jinx lives for at least another year. Spectacular Bid, in 1978, remains the last two-year-old champion to win the Kentucky Derby the following year. Why, 14 of the last 27 champion two-year-olds never even made it into the Derby starting gate.
Additionally, $60,150 in Churchill Downs Pool 1 of the Kentucky Derby Futures Bet is now down the drain faster than you can say flush. Sorcerer’s Stone finished Pool 1 at 30-1 odds, accounting for only $9,982 in wagers. However, Stevie Wonderboy was the second wagering choice in Pool 1, garnering $50,168 of the action while the mutuel field led the way at 3-1 with $115,000 wagered. At least with the field, if you lose a horse you still have over 400 others as a backup. Not so with the Eclipse Award winner, who will now be pointed for a late summer campaign leading to the Breeders’ Cup Classic, according to owner Merv Griffin. How appropriately ironic that two of the game shows he devised are Wheel of Fortune and Jeopardy.
The Questions Begin
Now that the thrill of Saturday has passed and Afleet Alex has established himself as a most superior horse, the question of how he failed to become the first Triple Crown winner in 27 years is coming to the fore. “How did the colt who is clearly the best runner in his generation fail to win the 2005 Triple Crown?,” asks Rick Bozich (Courier-Journal). Bill Finley answers: “The only possible answer? It’s just a very, very hard thing to do” (ESPN). Expect this conversation to continue for years as people debate whether it was the jockey or the pace that cost Alex the Kentucky Derby.
—
Trainer Tim Ritchey said “at least 15 breeding farms have inquired about Afleet Alex,” but that if an interest in the colt is sold it would be only for breeding and wouldn’t interfere with Ritchey’s racing plans (LA Times). The owners are “adamant” about seeing Alex run as a four-year-old. Cash Is King managing partner Chuck Zacney told Boston Globe reporter Ron Indrisano, “We never got into this for the money. I think he’s going to get better with age. We’re so attracted to Alex, and there are so many people attracted to this horse, that I’d hate to see an end to the trip. At the end of October, after the Breeders’ Cup [Oct. 29 at Belmont], if all goes well, I think we’ll probably start entertaining offers. But I don’t see anything before that.” I want to believe. Keeping the amazing Alex in training would be great for the sport, and there’s no reason to doubt the sincerity of Zacney or Ritchey, but:
There’s been a parade of breeders lining up to swipe Afleet Alex faster than he stormed through that opening Saturday. Take WinStar Farm’s Doug Cauthen, who was headed to Belmont Park late Thursday see to Afleet Alex. When Cauthen’s flight was canceled, he jumped in a rental car and drove all night.
Around the barn, figures in the millions to syndicate Afleet Alex are being tossed about. In a matter of minutes, it’s clear those are ridiculous numbers, because the next set of numbers you hear are much, much larger.
“It really is out of our hands,” [Afleet Alex co-owner Bob] Brittingham said. “I don’t know. I’d like to see him run till he’s 5, 6, 7. At least through 4 years, just because he’s that good and I know he likes to run, and I’d like to see him run against some of my heroes that are still out there — Ghostzapper, Lost in the Fog. I’d love to see that.”
Pause.
“I don’t know if we actually get to make that decision.” (Palm Beach Post)
—
Speaking of Ritchey, it’s time to heap praise upon him for the unconventional training regimen he devised for Afleet Alex. Sending the colt out to the track twice a day to jog and/or gallop up to five miles worked wonders. “If [Ritchey] doesn’t win the Eclipse Award for his skill, creativity, patience and graciousness, I’ll be surprised,” writes Ray Kerrison in the New York Post. “Ritchey made absolutely sure to maximize the colt’s potential by having him so physically fit that he was able to run the final 440 yards of the Belmont Stakes as if he was going downhill,” says Dick Jerardi, reporting that Ritchey looked to the 1970s for inspiration:
“I had a conversation with Ron Turcotte that was pretty interesting,” Ritchey said. “He said Secretariat galloped 3 miles many days. I know how those older trainers trained. I’ve been a student of the game.
“I’ve always thought if I got this opportunity, I’m not going to have a horse that’s going to run a mile-and-a-half that’s only going to train a mile-and-a-half. It logically doesn’t make sense.” (Philadelphia Inquirer)
Can there be any question that it was the hard training — combined with a rigorous racing schedule — that made Afleet Alex so athletic in the Preakness and so dominant in the Belmont?
The Sunday New York Times ran an oddly-placed lament on the decline of stamina horses in American racing. The article’s premise — that there was no Triple Crown this year because horses are bred for speed, not staying — didn’t make much sense in light of Alex’s Belmont win. Here was a horse with a pedigree that didn’t suggest he’d get the mile and a half distance with the ease that he did. Yet Alex won by seven lengths after running the fastest final quarter since 1969. It makes me wonder — is the problem that horses are no longer bred for stamina, or that they’re no longer trained for stamina? I’d lean toward the latter.
More Belmont
A mere 62,274 were at Belmont on Saturday to watch the awesome Afleet Alex win the Belmont Stakes (Blood-Horse). With no Triple Crown on the line, the crowd was half of what it was in 2004, and Saturday’s attendance was the lowest for the Belmont since 1996.
Attendance wasn’t the only thing down this year. TV ratings for the Belmont dropped 63% (Boston Globe). Wagering was up, however. A record was set for the non-Triple Crown running of the Belmont, with more than $47.9 million wagered on the race (Thoroughbred Times). Handle for all 13 races on the card was in excess of $87.5 million, another record for a non-Triple Crown card.
—
With his triumph yesterday, Afleet Alex became the eleventh horse to lose the Kentucky Derby but win the Preakness and Belmont. Rider Jeremy Rose expressed some regret over that: “He should be a Triple Crown winner, but I messed up or whatever,” he said after the race. “You can’t blame Tim, and you can’t blame Afleet Alex. So if you have to blame someone, blame me. I don’t want to hear any more criticism about my horse. Knock me, but don’t knock him. He’s one of the best we’ll see in a long time” (New York Times). I think Rose, who has demonstrated much talent and patience this spring, is being hard on himself. The Derby was a tough race with a brutal pace, and Alex only lost by a length. So he didn’t win the Triple Crown — he’s still unquestionably the best three-year-old in training right now.
Alex zipped the last quarter of the Belmont in 24.4 seconds, the fastest time since Arts and Letters in 1969, and his speedy surge caught some off guard. “I thought my horse could win the race,” said Rafael Bejarano, who was on Nolan’s Cat and only three lengths behind Alex coming out of the final turn. “I was very happy going into the turn,” said jockey Edgar Prado, who was riding Indy Storm, “but when I saw Afleet Alex going by me like I was tied to a pole, I said, ‘Oh, (shoot), I’m in trouble.’ He went by me so fast” (Courier Journal).
Trainer Tim Ritchey said Afleet Alex came out of yesterday’s race well and will be pointed to the Haskell on August 7 or the Travers on August 27 (Daily Racing Form), and affirmed that the colt would run as a four-year-old. But Ritchey played down an Afleet Alex-Ghostzapper meeting in the Breeders’ Cup Classic this October: “Ghostzapper is a tremendous horse. Our horse is a 3-year-old. We’re going to run him with 3-year-olds where he belongs right now. He will be running as a 4-year-old, so if Ghostzapper is still out there, I suppose we’ll meet up somewhere, but we’ll see what happens then. That’s a long way ahead” (Blood-Horse). Post Belmont, a four-year-old campaign might be a little problematic. Blood-Horse estimates that Afleet Alex’s stud value is $30 million right now.
—
Jockey Mike Smith explained Giacomo’s seventh place finish by saying that the Derby winner was agitated from the NYRA pre-race detention barn and flipped his palate before the Belmont (New York Daily News). The gray colt is already on his way back to California and will rest for a while before returning to the track, according to trainer John Shirreffs.
A bad break eliminated Reverberate from contention. ”We lost all chance when he stumbled at the start,” said trainer Sal Russo (Boston Globe). The race comment notes that Reverberate “broke in air,” and rider Jose Santos thought the colt was “anxious.” It was a shame to see Reverberate finish tenth yesterday. I was sure Afleet Alex was unbeatable, and almost as sure Reverberate would run second — although that didn’t stop me from tossing Andromeda’s Hero onto my ticket. All the talk early this spring about how strong he galloped out after races made me think Andromeda’s Hero might like the Belmont distance, which he did, finishing second. With that, Andromeda’s Hero became the only one of trainer Nick Zito’s record eleven starters in this year’s Triple Crown races to hit the board in those races.
About
Jessica Chapel writes and edits in Massachusetts. Railbird is a Thoroughbred horse racing blog published from June 2004 to July 2019. More / Contact
Elsewhere
Find Jessica on Pinboard and Instagram, Railbird on LibraryThing and Twitter.
Etc.
Links
Search
Boston Racing
Spreadsheets/Data
← Home
Copyright © 2000-2026 by Jessica Chapel. All rights reserved.